[GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
+40
Ametros
OBS.GS.§S
MLPOCG
Rafafidi
Mister Nikel
Valikdu
tylertoon2
Moodyman90
Aonee
Theta
Scootayay
Somber
Chimalpopica
Cptadder
Vergil
jacky2734
Katarn
FeatherDust
CamoBadger
Icy Shake
Kattlarv
Ki-Tarn
Stringtheory
Scyto Harmony
222222
Jeremyrush
Admiral Stoic Rum
Quotidian
Mikas
Kippershy
Meleagridis
Ketchup
Caoimhe
Sindri
RandomBlank
SilentCarto
RoboRed
O. Hinds
iLateralGX
WavemasterRyx
44 posters
Page 18 of 31
Page 18 of 31 • 1 ... 10 ... 17, 18, 19 ... 24 ... 31
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
tylertoon2 wrote:Hey I'm sure you guys have already seen this but...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4LohgzBKXLY&lc=QGkiRPmsMpA0inCNLQPYqxoyMbSNs_xUw2mzNCt-62A&lch=email_reply&feature=em-comment_reply_received
I think a lot of you could really help out this project especially with writing and design.
I like that song, but... do you mean this or something similar? Only I don't think the Friendship is Witchcraft team needs help with writing and design. Sorry if I'm off base!
Guest- Guest
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
Overlong Analysis Cobalt wrote:tylertoon2 wrote:Hey I'm sure you guys have already seen this but...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4LohgzBKXLY&lc=QGkiRPmsMpA0inCNLQPYqxoyMbSNs_xUw2mzNCt-62A&lch=email_reply&feature=em-comment_reply_received
I think a lot of you could really help out this project especially with writing and design.
I like that song, but... do you mean this or something similar? Only I don't think the Friendship is Witchcraft team needs help with writing and design. Sorry if I'm off base!
WHOOPS SORRY
WRONG LINK https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1C6VP0h1XkM
Yeah thats what I was talking about
doy
Last edited by tylertoon2 on Sun Jul 29, 2012 5:39 pm; edited 1 time in total
tylertoon2- Hydra
- Posts : 642
Brohoof! : 51
Join date : 2012-05-18
Age : 28
Character List:
Name:
Sex:
Species:
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
Yes, some of the people here can help with familiarity with the universe, if not more.Overlong Analysis Cobalt wrote:
I like that song, but... do you mean this or something similar? Only I don't think the Friendship is Witchcraft team needs help with writing and design. Sorry if I'm off base!
Ketchup- The Condiment
- Posts : 4891
Brohoof! : 114
Join date : 2012-05-09
Age : 26
Location : New Brunswick, Canada
Character List:
Name:
Sex:
Species:
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
I dunno what that thing in your avatar is, but it's oddly cute. :3MLPOCG wrote:I'm not sure if this is the appropriate place to post this, but here is my review of Project Horizons after reading to the end of the latest chapter :3
Can you explain your problem with these "simultaneous events" more clearly? I don't understand what you're complaining about.
Well, speaking as a GM, pressure is an important thing to add to a scene. Without the griffon, she could take her time picking her way up the stairs and there's no real threat. With the griffon in pursuit, she can't do that. She has to rush and take chances, which is what makes an exciting scene. For my money, the "ninjas attack" style of writing isn't a bad thing; it suggests that the enemies are in motion too, rather than just sitting in their 10x10 rooms waiting for the PCs to kick in the door.Somber wrote:I didn't need that scene. I could have removed it entirely and had the hazard simply be the stairs. But that didn't seem quite like enough. So I threw in the griffon.
SilentCarto- Alicorn
- Posts : 1585
Brohoof! : 393
Join date : 2012-05-08
Age : 44
Location : Texas
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
@Swicked: Well, I guess if going with "good Christian values" or whatever to call it (a "being tired and cold" reply before going to bed btw, so these might be a bit messy), the mane six should all be expected to have foals of their own and whatnot if ~25+. And they'd be shown doing, I dunno, paying bills and being responsible adults and whatnot? Being just teens allow them more to "go on adventures" and be that "inspiring sister" instead of more of a mother figure or, something. I dunno really. Since as said, you don't (that often) relate to or idolize those much older than you, you want to be like the hip and cool teens. (just talking "business wise" here. Just take Ice age 3.. or was 4 the latest? anyhow, that movie has "this is how we think teens are", hollywood style.)Since after all, if you were ~7, would you prefer to think your favourite pony was ~15, and somewhere you could be kinda close to the same age as, could grow up to be like her, or that she is around 25-30, and could be your mom? In most cases, you already have your mom. And as said, I dunno how marketing works, but them being all young go-getters with their own dreams and hobbies and whatnot would seem to appear more "appealing" to young girls I think. (since as said, compare what you'd likely most want if you were ~7, a ~15 year old "sibling/acquaintance" that likely more "down" with stuff you like and whatnot, or a ~30 something "role model" that more is there to guide you and.. stuff.) And as said, Equestria isn't Earth, maybe 13-15 would be considered "adult enough", they seem to partially have rather carefree lives... to an extent, not including all the monsters and random shit ^^' But it seems a tad bit less harsh than earth, so a teen proprietor(is that the right word?) might actually be able to do just fine. And going with how they seem rather "specialized" in their work, the technical use for higher overall education might not be needed unless they want to learn more.
@Cao: Spoiler due to length, and prodding a bit on one of the "preferably not mentioned" areas.
@Eru: Just random on the ages: I can just pitch in that it's not that uncommon in quite a few parts in USA and likely elsewhere to be expected to be married when around 16-20. Mostly since it being so hyped and yadda yadda, and the whole "no sex before marriage" thing. (so annoyed Lauren was made to put that in a comment, not sure if it could've been her, but feels like something she was asked to do.)
@Tyler: Firstly, listened the shit out of that song, especially one of the extended ones xP
Secondly, will check the vid out tomorrow, seems interesting.
Anyhow, off to bed now, and will actually try to just relax tomorrow. Unless I get a surprise inspiration, like that'd happen xD
And totally random: I drank water the other day, and it actually tasted not bad, that the first time in months, almost a year ever since I got my tonsils removed.
@Cao: Spoiler due to length, and prodding a bit on one of the "preferably not mentioned" areas.
- Spoiler:
- I agree with that the scene was good in that manor, and being overly tired atm, I won't be able to give properly good reply, but I can try and make a point. One of the few things I can recall at the moment was that it could have been a chance for BJ to "mare up" and learn to take control herself of the matter, but she went with folding. And that was a bit disappointing for me, but all and all, it's what she's used to, she does what she's told. Second was that she "counted male", and going with all her life experience, sex was about feeling good and making the mare orgasm (or well, satisfy the mare, some might be into other stuff), the male isn't important, they are just tools for their amusement, unless the one time they were used to impregnate, then their orgasm was actually needed, none other time was this really important to even think off, unless they as said: wanted the male to. So that she suddenly revolved the whole act of sex around the male quite goes against everything she's "been told" and grew up with. Now granted, it is possible BJ was one of the "weird fucks" in 99 that liked giving it to others, but for all other evidence we've seen, she's been a "receiver", she values her pleasure the most, and sex is about pleasure. (unless I am totally remembering all previous sex mentions with BJ wrong) And up till a few weeks back, all she knew of sex was that it was that, then she met Glory, who had "crazy ideas" about why one would have sex and stuff, ideas that previously countered with "productivity" and the loyalty to the overmare. This was what she was told when growing up in 99 as said.
->
So her suddenly counting a males orgasms, and not really caring for her own is just a strange swap of personality/PoV imo (the first one I can get and excuse, but then it just keeps going and adding up to her letting herself be "used like a male" (and dunno of you were here then, but we had a long discussion of Styg doing a poor job overall and being selfish and stuff like that due to not seeming at all to care for BJ to orgasm, some saying that "she was okay with it", indicating Styg could read her mind and thus it was cool. Others, myself included pointing out that one thought he ought to like, notice or something after x amount of orgasms that he is not the only one involved in that sex that can climax) and treating her own as a "oh hey, neat, an optional part of sex." (since as said, she "actually managed", indicating it was more of a "accident/bi-product" of Styg getting himself off yet another time. As said, I can't speak for BJ, but one would think she'd "come to" after the 2'nd or 3'rd go, since she seemed to "improve" her view on it a ton after the first. Thirdly was that she went straight for the "big test", granted, she is a "gambler", and I know "easing her way there" might have been awkward and more "cloppy", but to me, it seemed like a much safer choice, and I didn't see BJ as showing wanting to risk hurting or killing Styg at that point, yet she went for one of the most risky ways to "test/make sure" she could take it. (and to the rest, sorry for rambling about this again, but it happens when I'm tired.)
->
And just a small side note, I don't know what it says about BJ, but I found it rather both amusing and perplexing when she mentioned about Styg to Glory, bragging how he was a really great lay, despite stating to herself that he "wasn't bad... but not very good either", I think he was described as "do-able/decent/it works". Not sure what it says about her as said, since as said, she didn't say anything about her performance, indicating she possibly doesn't really care how she is in bed, granted, she acted "sack of potatoes" the first couple of times. I'm quite confused as to what she was trying to indicate. Since yes, she did say she got over her trauma (and randomly, quite sure you wasn't here then as it was back in EQD, but judging by Sombers reaction to the topic of "male non-con" (males as the "target"), it would indicate that I'm possibly not the (possibly) only one with a first hand experience with the matter as a whole. And cannot give or make any accurate claim, but there seems to be a possible underlying issue with that for Somber, going with the amount of female non-con. Leaving 99 mainly just being a " strange, fucked up place" for such thing to even exist there. Kkat just failed and messed up in that matter (or just have a really strong fetish for it, but hates the former. Going with her previous works), Somber has at least gingerly poked at one part while having body slammed the other part, so to speak. And now I'm trailing off again. But yeah, if so, Somber definitely dealt with it some other way, or despite saying BJ has to deal with it, haven't themselves. Or possibly "lived out" (is that the term) theirs through BJ. Or got mental revenge, I am not sure.) but back to the point: As said, not sure what BJ was aiming for here, saying she is bad in the sack? Trying to brag that she had sex? Trying to help boost Styg's ego? I'm just trailing off here xP
@Eru: Just random on the ages: I can just pitch in that it's not that uncommon in quite a few parts in USA and likely elsewhere to be expected to be married when around 16-20. Mostly since it being so hyped and yadda yadda, and the whole "no sex before marriage" thing. (so annoyed Lauren was made to put that in a comment, not sure if it could've been her, but feels like something she was asked to do.)
@Tyler: Firstly, listened the shit out of that song, especially one of the extended ones xP
Secondly, will check the vid out tomorrow, seems interesting.
Anyhow, off to bed now, and will actually try to just relax tomorrow. Unless I get a surprise inspiration, like that'd happen xD
And totally random: I drank water the other day, and it actually tasted not bad, that the first time in months, almost a year ever since I got my tonsils removed.
Kattlarv- Hydra
- Posts : 560
Brohoof! : 27
Join date : 2012-05-10
Location : Sweden
Character List:
Name: Dewflower
Sex: Female-ish
Species: Unicorn
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
On the issue of scene transitions I can only respectfully disagree, I recognize that my taste for such disruptive transitions is entirely personal. On the issue of director's cut inclusions, though, you can't blame Somber. The Author asked us what we wanted, and we said that we wanted every last drop of Project Horizons until all that was left became a shrivelled raisin. So that isn't the author's fault- it is ours.MLPOCG wrote:
- Spoiler:
Further elaborating on technique, another large
issue is awkward scene transitions, I have counted four cases of a
chapter ending on a calm note, only to find in the next chapter the hero
and his friends are somewhere completely different or in the middle of a
side quest. These scene transitions are jarring and have left me
confused on more than one occasion, making me look at the previous
chapter just in case I skipped ahead. Another issue is the inclusion of a
few scenarios that feel unnecessary, one in particular is in the later
chapters when Blackjack is separated from her friends and meets many
side characters who will most likely appear later (and one who is a permanent ally), but the separation
from her friends felt random and these chapters weren’t quite as
enjoyable to read since the story’s most compelling aspect is the
characters and their relationships, I felt that a small contingent of her group could have joined her for these parts. Finally, there are some characters
who just feel plain unnecessary at the point of this review such as
Precious, who has had hardly any dialogue so far and really came out of nowhere.
On characters, I can't speak for any unspoken, but Precious has not had a chance to play beyond the role of defeated enemy yet. Remember that she is living at HQ right now with all the potential disaster or salvation she may bring. There are still a few mines in Chapel, and not all of them are buried in the ground.
To everything else... yup. That was a well written review. Thanks for putting it out there.
May I second this?Caoimhe wrote:
Somber, I'd like to see some of the tools and notes you use in your writing to keep track of your plot lines and characters. I find writing techniques and behind the scenes stuff fascinating for some reason.
Duh... huh. Well. Uh.tylertoon2 wrote:Hey I'm sure you guys have already seen this but...
What are the odds that Somber would have the time...?
Meleagridis- Ursa Major
- Posts : 866
Brohoof! : 134
Join date : 2012-05-09
Location : Location, Location
Character List:
Name:
Sex:
Species:
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
Off topic, spoilery ranting. I saw the new Batman movie today, and I was underwhelmed. I need to rant, and you guys are my audience.
Sorry...
Sorry...
- Spoilers - The Dark Knight Rises:
The one unmitigated compliment I can make to this movie is that I never looked at something and thought, "That was CGI." The effects were top-notch.
My impression of "The Dark Knight Rises" is, in a word, 'half-assed'. It's written in the shape of a Batman plot, but almost every aspect is kind of lame and only partially explained. This feeling emerged pretty much as soon as Christian Bayle appeared on screen, and continued through the whole thing.
To begin with, Bane. He isn't the 'roided up brickhouse we expect. Instead he's a showy, erudite, card-carrying villain mastermind who manages to stay a step ahead of even Batman. Granted, that's because he has inside info from Talia al Ghul, but more on that later. I didn't ever get the sense that Batman was utterly outclassed in the physical arena. Bane informed us that he isn't susceptible to all Batman's usual trickery and gadgets, but they never showed it except for one half-assed shock tactic with a small handful of firecrackers. Batman just gamely swung in every time, meeting Bane force-on-force instead of employing the brains-over-brawn tactics that every other incarnation of Bane has required. They even did the whole "Breaking of the Bat" scene, but it just gave him this half-assed chiropractic problem rather than a truly crippling injury.
An aside about Batman's tactics: I would have enjoyed seeing Bruce put all his ninja training to use WITHOUT the cape and cowl after the mask was destroyed by Bane, showing that it's the man that's important, not the mask. But no, he just derps around the city, playing the semi-clueless playboy until Morgan Freeman pulls yet another new bat-suit out of his ass. You know, I find it harder to be impressed with Batman when he's wearing 20 pounds of armor at all times. We didn't really get to see him doing any investigative work in this one, he just walks in and starts kicking people.
Continuing: Bane's backstory doesn't make any sense at all in retrospect. His entire thesis was that he could beat Batman because he was the Child of the Pit, grew up in the darkness, the dark is his friend, etc. So when it turns out the Child was actually Talia, where does that leave him?!
Bane and Talia's plan is utterly half-baked as well. What's the point of all this showmanship, cutting off the city and letting it fall into chaos before they just go ahead and blow it up anyway? Was it supposed to prove some kind of point to the world? Some point other than "It's a good thing we locked up the people we locked up in Blackgate, because look what they did when released and armed"? It seems a little over-complicated if it was just a revenge scheme against Batman himself when they could have just captured him, stripped him, and tossed him in the Pit.
Not to mention, the badguys were apparently psychic. How could they possibly expect to trap the entire police force underground, when they were only there because their subterranean army was uncovered due to Gordon failing to die in their bomb trap and then getting captured by two idiots who brought him in to see it, followed by him effecting his own escape?
Oh, but he's not the only clairvoyant in the movie. Somehow, Officer Robin Blake realized that Gordon vanishing after an explosion in the sewer meant he would shortly be washing out of some anonymous storm drain that even the bad guys couldn't predict. The entire scene of flushing Idiot #2 after Gordon for tracking purposes didn't even come up again, because Gordon was rescued right out of the drain and taken to the hospital before Bane could do anything about it.
Speaking of which, where does Bane come up with hundreds of violent offenders with military training, and not have any of them get caught up in Homeland Security screenings? You're telling me every one of these guys, despite being a hardened mercenary killer, has no record whatsoever? Enough so that they could work on government construction jobs and buy the precursor products for explosives?
The short-lived romance with Talia was very half-assed. It came out of absolutely nowhere, as if 10 minutes of her and Bruce getting together were left on the cutting room floor.
Jumping forward to Bruce in the Pit, I don't understand this prison at all. The inmates are pretty much left to their own devices; are you telling me there's not enough material in there to build a ladder across that big jump so everyone can climb out? They seem to live together in relative peace, so what's to keep them from working together to get out of this hellhole? Who's enforcing the rules? If this were a level in Lemmings, I'd have it beat in five minutes! (Less, actually, if I had the Climber tool.)
This is a fairly minor gripe, but when Batman and Bane are striding through the big pitched battle to have their own private throwdown, I really would have liked to see some cop swing around and empty a clip of 9mm into Bane's ass and see how well he fights after that. Of course, the same could be said for Batman. However, I got really sick of the mooks on both sides trying to shoot people by running within arm's reach. It doesn't make Bane and Batman look awesome, it makes everyone else look like a drooling moron. Similarly, while the police and criminals clashing was a cool image, it would really be more convincing if both sides went scrambling for cover instead.
Also, the scene where Batman had to evade a bunch of missiles in the Batwing involved the slowest, longest-burning surface-to-air missiles I've ever seen. I guess you're just screwed if you want to shoot down anything that moves faster than highway traffic. PROTIP: You can pull off this kind of scene with a jet fighter or a spaceship. NOT with a fucking helicopter.
SilentCarto- Alicorn
- Posts : 1585
Brohoof! : 393
Join date : 2012-05-08
Age : 44
Location : Texas
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
Hey guys, quick question since I haven't downloaded the story like some of you, but what's the word count of all the released chapters so far? The FO:E wiki tags it at 945k so far, but I don't know if it's up to date.
Aonee- Draconequus
- Posts : 12338
Brohoof! : 98
Join date : 2012-05-11
Age : 28
Location : East Texas
Character List:
Name:
Sex:
Species:
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
975,870 using the PDF.
The text file weighs in at 66MB.
The text file weighs in at 66MB.
Caoimhe- Alicorn
- Posts : 1182
Brohoof! : 264
Join date : 2012-07-11
Location : Providence, RI
Character List:
Name: Comma, Splice
Sex: Female
Species: Sentence fragment
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
And my friends were impressed when they heard that FO:E was 645ish thousand words long.
Aonee- Draconequus
- Posts : 12338
Brohoof! : 98
Join date : 2012-05-11
Age : 28
Location : East Texas
Character List:
Name:
Sex:
Species:
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
You could read Jane Eyre five and a half times or you could read PH. Tough choice!
Note: I'm not trying to be anti-intellectual, Jane Eyre is awful trash that has no use being taught in school. It has very literary merit other its age. It is also unreasonably boring.
Note: I'm not trying to be anti-intellectual, Jane Eyre is awful trash that has no use being taught in school. It has very literary merit other its age. It is also unreasonably boring.
Caoimhe- Alicorn
- Posts : 1182
Brohoof! : 264
Join date : 2012-07-11
Location : Providence, RI
Character List:
Name: Comma, Splice
Sex: Female
Species: Sentence fragment
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
SilentCarto wrote:Off topic, spoilery ranting. I saw the new Batman movie today, and I was underwhelmed. I need to rant, and you guys are my audience.
Sorry...
- Spoilers - The Dark Knight Rises:
The one unmitigated compliment I can make to this movie is that I never looked at something and thought, "That was CGI." The effects were top-notch.
My impression of "The Dark Knight Rises" is, in a word, 'half-assed'. It's written in the shape of a Batman plot, but almost every aspect is kind of lame and only partially explained. This feeling emerged pretty much as soon as Christian Bayle appeared on screen, and continued through the whole thing.
To begin with, Bane. He isn't the 'roided up brickhouse we expect. Instead he's a showy, erudite, card-carrying villain mastermind who manages to stay a step ahead of even Batman. Granted, that's because he has inside info from Talia al Ghul, but more on that later. I didn't ever get the sense that Batman was utterly outclassed in the physical arena. Bane informed us that he isn't susceptible to all Batman's usual trickery and gadgets, but they never showed it except for one half-assed shock tactic with a small handful of firecrackers. Batman just gamely swung in every time, meeting Bane force-on-force instead of employing the brains-over-brawn tactics that every other incarnation of Bane has required. They even did the whole "Breaking of the Bat" scene, but it just gave him this half-assed chiropractic problem rather than a truly crippling injury.
An aside about Batman's tactics: I would have enjoyed seeing Bruce put all his ninja training to use WITHOUT the cape and cowl after the mask was destroyed by Bane, showing that it's the man that's important, not the mask. But no, he just derps around the city, playing the semi-clueless playboy until Morgan Freeman pulls yet another new bat-suit out of his ass. You know, I find it harder to be impressed with Batman when he's wearing 20 pounds of armor at all times. We didn't really get to see him doing any investigative work in this one, he just walks in and starts kicking people.
Continuing: Bane's backstory doesn't make any sense at all in retrospect. His entire thesis was that he could beat Batman because he was the Child of the Pit, grew up in the darkness, the dark is his friend, etc. So when it turns out the Child was actually Talia, where does that leave him?!
Bane and Talia's plan is utterly half-baked as well. What's the point of all this showmanship, cutting off the city and letting it fall into chaos before they just go ahead and blow it up anyway? Was it supposed to prove some kind of point to the world? Some point other than "It's a good thing we locked up the people we locked up in Blackgate, because look what they did when released and armed"? It seems a little over-complicated if it was just a revenge scheme against Batman himself when they could have just captured him, stripped him, and tossed him in the Pit.
Not to mention, the bad guys were apparently psychic. How could they possibly expect to trap the entire police force underground, when they were only there because their subterranean army was uncovered due to Gordon failing to die in their bomb trap and then getting captured by two idiots who brought him in to see it, followed by him effecting his own escape?
Oh, but he's not the only clairvoyant in the movie. Somehow, Officer Robin Blake realized that Gordon vanishing after an explosion in the sewer meant he would shortly be washing out of some anonymous storm drain that even the bad guys couldn't predict. The entire scene of flushing Idiot #2 after Gordon for tracking purposes didn't even come up again, because Gordon was rescued right out of the drain and taken to the hospital before Bane could do anything about it.
Speaking of which, where does Bane come up with hundreds of violent offenders with military training, and not have any of them get caught up in Homeland Security screenings? You're telling me every one of these guys, despite being a hardened mercenary killer, has no record whatsoever? Enough so that they could work on government construction jobs and buy the precursor products for explosives?
The short-lived romance with Talia was very half-assed. It came out of absolutely nowhere, as if 10 minutes of her and Bruce getting together were left on the cutting room floor.
Jumping forward to Bruce in the Pit, I don't understand this prison at all. The inmates are pretty much left to their own devices; are you telling me there's not enough material in there to build a ladder across that big jump so everyone can climb out? They seem to live together in relative peace, so what's to keep them from working together to get out of this hellhole? Who's enforcing the rules? If this were a level in Lemmings, I'd have it beat in five minutes! (Less, actually, if I had the Climber tool.)
This is a fairly minor gripe, but when Batman and Bane are striding through the big pitched battle to have their own private throwdown, I really would have liked to see some cop swing around and empty a clip of 9mm into Bane's ass and see how well he fights after that. Of course, the same could be said for Batman. However, I got really sick of the mooks on both sides trying to shoot people by running within arm's reach. It doesn't make Bane and Batman look awesome, it makes everyone else look like a drooling moron. Similarly, while the police and criminals clashing was a cool image, it would really be more convincing if both sides went scrambling for cover instead.
Also, the scene where Batman had to evade a bunch of missiles in the Batwing involved the slowest, longest-burning surface-to-air missiles I've ever seen. I guess you're just screwed if you want to shoot down anything that moves faster than highway traffic. PROTIP: You can pull off this kind of scene with a jet fighter or a spaceship. NOT with a fucking helicopter.
I saw it a week ago, it wasn't a bad movie but the second one was better IMO (I never saw the first one so I can't compare/comment on that one)
all of your points are totally valid and I agree with them completely in hindsight (I do believe this is called Fridge Logic), though I do have to add that for your manpower point, where did Joker's guys get the RPG for that tunnel car chase/battle, aren't those EXTREMELY illegal? well I guess they could've made it, but still, most superhero run semi-entirely on Willing Suspension of Disbelief and lots of Phlebotinum, but usually Batman tries to be at least somewhat grounded in reality
Stringtheory- Alicorn
- Posts : 2097
Brohoof! : 97
Join date : 2012-05-13
Age : 28
Location : Amherst, MA
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
swicked wrote:I haven't seen the new movie, but at that point, didn't he have the combined wealth and resources of all the major crime groups in gotham? I figure he had enough cash behind him to raid a military base, assuming one hadn't been raided beforehand by said crime families.stringtheory wrote:where did Joker's guys get the RPG for that tunnel car chase/battle, aren't those EXTREMELY illegal?
um, last time I checked Gotham was in America (and is an expo of New York), and that military bases are EXTREMELY well fortified, and even if they did manage to succeed, they military would be hunting them down with a high level of urgency, my personal theory is that they bought it through an arms dealer or built it themselves
Stringtheory- Alicorn
- Posts : 2097
Brohoof! : 97
Join date : 2012-05-13
Age : 28
Location : Amherst, MA
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
No, I agree. In fact, I have something similar to say about many of the books taught in school, and I feel that forcing children to read boring book after boring book tends to cause many to conclude that reading is boring, rather than concluding that this particular book is boring. Because after three or four, pattern recognition kicks in...Caoimhe wrote:Note: I'm not trying to be anti-intellectual, Jane Eyre is awful trash that has no use being taught in school. It has very literary merit other its age. It is also unreasonably boring.
Fridge Logic only applies if you don't notice it while watching the movie. :pstringtheory wrote:all of your points are totally valid and I agree with them completely in hindsight (I do believe this is called Fridge Logic), though I do have to add that for your manpower point, where did Joker's guys get the RPG for that tunnel car chase/battle, aren't those EXTREMELY illegal? well I guess they could've made it, but still, most superhero run semi-entirely on Willing Suspension of Disbelief and lots of Phlebotinum, but usually Batman tries to be at least somewhat grounded in reality
Where criminals in Batman get their weapons is indeed a bit of a "suspension of disbelief" matter. Presumably there was a back alley, an Eastern European man, and a briefcase with money in it. I don't generally nitpick matters like that -- I'll stipulate that you could probably acquire a handful of illegal weapons or sneak a small team of mercenaries into wherever for the purposes of an interesting story occurring. But when the badguy has enough manpower to undermine large swaths of the city unnoticed, each so unswervingly loyal as to sacrifice himself for the cause, it does tend to stretch credibility.
Last edited by SilentCarto on Sun Jul 29, 2012 11:50 pm; edited 1 time in total
SilentCarto- Alicorn
- Posts : 1585
Brohoof! : 393
Join date : 2012-05-08
Age : 44
Location : Texas
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
Yeah pretty much. I will admit, I don't actually read that many comics, but unless they're name then yeah, most cops are either corrupt or incompetent. Or both.
Good example of this is Batman Arkahm Asylum. I think other then Commissioner Gordon there was only one or two cops that survived the night. And one, Arron Cash, had been in the comics before.
Good example of this is Batman Arkahm Asylum. I think other then Commissioner Gordon there was only one or two cops that survived the night. And one, Arron Cash, had been in the comics before.
Moodyman90- Draconequus
- Posts : 8257
Brohoof! : 163
Join date : 2012-05-09
Age : 34
Character List:
Name: Moody Blues/ Moodstone
Sex: Male/ Male
Species: Earth Pony/ Unicorn
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
SilentCarto wrote:Off topic, spoilery ranting. I saw the new Batman movie today, and I was underwhelmed. I need to rant, and you guys are my audience.
Sorry...
- Spoilers - The Dark Knight Rises:
The one unmitigated compliment I can make to this movie is that I never looked at something and thought, "That was CGI." The effects were top-notch.
My impression of "The Dark Knight Rises" is, in a word, 'half-assed'. It's written in the shape of a Batman plot, but almost every aspect is kind of lame and only partially explained. This feeling emerged pretty much as soon as Christian Bayle appeared on screen, and continued through the whole thing.
To begin with, Bane. He isn't the 'roided up brickhouse we expect. Instead he's a showy, erudite, card-carrying villain mastermind who manages to stay a step ahead of even Batman. Granted, that's because he has inside info from Talia al Ghul, but more on that later. I didn't ever get the sense that Batman was utterly outclassed in the physical arena. Bane informed us that he isn't susceptible to all Batman's usual trickery and gadgets, but they never showed it except for one half-assed shock tactic with a small handful of firecrackers. Batman just gamely swung in every time, meeting Bane force-on-force instead of employing the brains-over-brawn tactics that every other incarnation of Bane has required. They even did the whole "Breaking of the Bat" scene, but it just gave him this half-assed chiropractic problem rather than a truly crippling injury.
An aside about Batman's tactics: I would have enjoyed seeing Bruce put all his ninja training to use WITHOUT the cape and cowl after the mask was destroyed by Bane, showing that it's the man that's important, not the mask. But no, he just derps around the city, playing the semi-clueless playboy until Morgan Freeman pulls yet another new bat-suit out of his ass. You know, I find it harder to be impressed with Batman when he's wearing 20 pounds of armor at all times. We didn't really get to see him doing any investigative work in this one, he just walks in and starts kicking people.
Continuing: Bane's backstory doesn't make any sense at all in retrospect. His entire thesis was that he could beat Batman because he was the Child of the Pit, grew up in the darkness, the dark is his friend, etc. So when it turns out the Child was actually Talia, where does that leave him?!
Bane and Talia's plan is utterly half-baked as well. What's the point of all this showmanship, cutting off the city and letting it fall into chaos before they just go ahead and blow it up anyway? Was it supposed to prove some kind of point to the world? Some point other than "It's a good thing we locked up the people we locked up in Blackgate, because look what they did when released and armed"? It seems a little over-complicated if it was just a revenge scheme against Batman himself when they could have just captured him, stripped him, and tossed him in the Pit.
Not to mention, the badguys were apparently psychic. How could they possibly expect to trap the entire police force underground, when they were only there because their subterranean army was uncovered due to Gordon failing to die in their bomb trap and then getting captured by two idiots who brought him in to see it, followed by him effecting his own escape?
Oh, but he's not the only clairvoyant in the movie. Somehow, Officer Robin Blake realized that Gordon vanishing after an explosion in the sewer meant he would shortly be washing out of some anonymous storm drain that even the bad guys couldn't predict. The entire scene of flushing Idiot #2 after Gordon for tracking purposes didn't even come up again, because Gordon was rescued right out of the drain and taken to the hospital before Bane could do anything about it.
Speaking of which, where does Bane come up with hundreds of violent offenders with military training, and not have any of them get caught up in Homeland Security screenings? You're telling me every one of these guys, despite being a hardened mercenary killer, has no record whatsoever? Enough so that they could work on government construction jobs and buy the precursor products for explosives?
The short-lived romance with Talia was very half-assed. It came out of absolutely nowhere, as if 10 minutes of her and Bruce getting together were left on the cutting room floor.
Jumping forward to Bruce in the Pit, I don't understand this prison at all. The inmates are pretty much left to their own devices; are you telling me there's not enough material in there to build a ladder across that big jump so everyone can climb out? They seem to live together in relative peace, so what's to keep them from working together to get out of this hellhole? Who's enforcing the rules? If this were a level in Lemmings, I'd have it beat in five minutes! (Less, actually, if I had the Climber tool.)
This is a fairly minor gripe, but when Batman and Bane are striding through the big pitched battle to have their own private throwdown, I really would have liked to see some cop swing around and empty a clip of 9mm into Bane's ass and see how well he fights after that. Of course, the same could be said for Batman. However, I got really sick of the mooks on both sides trying to shoot people by running within arm's reach. It doesn't make Bane and Batman look awesome, it makes everyone else look like a drooling moron. Similarly, while the police and criminals clashing was a cool image, it would really be more convincing if both sides went scrambling for cover instead.
Also, the scene where Batman had to evade a bunch of missiles in the Batwing involved the slowest, longest-burning surface-to-air missiles I've ever seen. I guess you're just screwed if you want to shoot down anything that moves faster than highway traffic. PROTIP: You can pull off this kind of scene with a jet fighter or a spaceship. NOT with a fucking helicopter.
I had most of those same problems, and some others, mostly tied to the financial hacking that was used to move the "steal Wayne Industries" plot along. Spoiler'd because.
- Spoiler:
- For one thing, I felt Talia's actions didn't make a whole lot of sense: why was she so interested in sustainable energy? The al-Ghuls aren't environmental terrorists in this continuity; they are, frankly, vandals. Is it just a cover? If so, why? Did Ras maintain such a high profile?
And about the prison--where do the food and water come from? how are these people not dropping like flies to every single disease imaginable? shouldn't Talia be permanently stunted both mentally and physically due to malnutrition and childhood disease? since when can small, malnourished, disease-ridden children out-long-jump hardened criminals?
Why was Bane even in the movie? Seriously, he could have been cut and nothing would have been missed apart from the Talia reveal; even that could have been salvaged by putting her in a mask. His prison role could have been an entirely anonymous character. It actually makes more sense for Talia to directly run the resurgent League, rather than the outcast. If she's basically the prison-born Jesus-Superman-Hitler or whatever she is, she could take Batman out on her own; who cares if that's a change from the comic--it's not like the present characters are especially faithful! I guess I'm just a little pissed that the whole central conflict was a sham, and one that almost makes less sense in retrospect.
Now we get to the stuff that very few people likely care about: the financial and legal details. I bring these up largely because they really took me out of the movie. I guess that that happened rarely, but there were just so many little unnecessary errors that it just sort of lost me, and for much of the rest of the film I was thinking about this stuff in the back of my mind.
Regarding the desire to take over Wayne Industries: was that ever really explained? Maybe I just lost it in everything else, but did the Waynes run over that guy's puppy or something? And even given that it's a reasonable goal, did he at least exhaust legal options first? Even though Wayne seems still to be the majority shareholder, the directors and executives have a fiduciary responsibility to all the shareholders; it shouldn't be hard to demonstrate that Fox is failing that spectacularly, and almost certainly criminally lied on SEC filings regarding the development of the fusion reactor. He could probably be caught for Sarbanes-Oxely violations if the guy hired a team of forensic accountants, and that evidence could be forwarded to the DOJ.
Regarding the hacking: the place to do the hacking wouldn't be on the trading floor, but in the exchange servers. Also, they would need to get into the bank where Bruce did his private banking. What's more, they had him entered into futures contracts; that wouldn't even be done at the stock exchange (and as far as Gotham being an expo for New York goes, the options and futures exchanges are in Chicago, but that's neither here nor there). And even if that is waved away, futures marking-to-market would mean that the only way he could have lost so much money was over a single day, which would have triggered circuit breakers in trading of whatever stock was underlying the contracts. Oh, and let's remember that the Flash Crash taught us that trades will be rewound for much less of a disruption than the one that showed up in the movie; nothing that happened after the break-in would stick.
Oh, and just one last thing at the end (just like the show itself!)--was there even a flippin' point to having the detective named Robin? Sequel bait? Catering to weak-ass fans who want Robin to be involved, but don't know shit about Batman? Seriously, if you wanted to make the detective a name character, why not Montoya? Sure, it would make the character a woman, but it would make some sense, at least more than this. And I for one would go see a "Question" movie, if it were to be released and it looked better-done than, say, Green Lantern.
Anyway, sorry for the self-indulgent rants.
Icy Shake- Alicorn
- Posts : 1209
Brohoof! : 308
Join date : 2012-06-05
Age : 35
Location : Boston, MA
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
@Icy Shake: agree with you on all points. Just thought I'd point out that Talia wasn't interested in sustainable energy, she just pretended she was to get access to the reactor. While Fox's antics may have been illegal, they certainly kept the reactor hidden very well.
222222- Ursa Major
- Posts : 769
Brohoof! : 34
Join date : 2012-07-01
Character List:
Name:
Sex:
Species:
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
SilentCarto wrote:
Where criminals in Batman get their weapons is indeed a bit of a "suspension of disbelief" matter. Presumably there was a back alley, an Eastern European man, and a briefcase with money in it. I don't generally nitpick matters like that -- I'll stipulate that you could probably acquire a handful of illegal weapons or sneak a small team of mercenaries into wherever for the purposes of an interesting story occurring. But when the badguy has enough manpower to undermine large swaths of the city unnoticed, each so unswervingly loyal as to sacrifice himself for the cause, it does tend to stretch credibility.
- Spoiler:
- I had a weird headcanon for the film that basically said that Bane and Talia had reformed the League of Shadows' techniques, relying not on ninja-fu craziness but on basic terrorist stuff. Also, I had the idea that that "prison" was actually their training and recruitment facility now, among other things - it'd explain a lot. But yeah, there were probably plot holes that doesn't fix. Overall, I enjoyed the film, and liked a lot of the things it did (though I'd have preferred for Batman to have been losing that final fight with Bane, or at least to have been having a harder time - the whole batman-is-kinda-beaten-up-and-not-so-undefeatable-now thing was something I enjoyed).
Oh, and the Robin thing was silly and I hope it's more of a nod to the idea of Gotham needing a protector from time to time than actual sequel bait, because seriously.
Guest- Guest
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
Offering my opinions on the whole Batman movie thing (just gonna touch on a few points I've seen)
I'm not trying to crush anyone's opinions or points here, just offering my POV and opinions. Please don't flame me
- Spoiler:
Bane being involved: I believe they involved him because in the comics he was really the first villain Batman fought that whipped the shit out of him. It seemed like more of a throwback to that moment when Batman actually lost instead of coming out on top, a show that he is not completely invincible.
(Comic nerd time: It was assumed by me and a few of my friends that Ras al Ghul or Talia was actually the planner of everything, because Bane was never the mastermind of any plots in the Batman universe. He was always working for someone else [mercenary].)
Bane's forces and their armament: In the Batman universe, the League of Shadows has always been an unwavering group of fanatics who absolutely believe in what Ras and Talia have told them. They would have no issues sacrificing themselves due to this loyalty, and the belief that what they are fighting for is the only way to 'fix' the world (not gonna lie, I hold a large number of their beliefs myself).
For their weaponry, it wouldn't likely be difficult for a large, organized group such as the League of Shadows to gain such weaponry. They started off being a group of mercenaries lead by Ras al Ghul, so they likely had connections to get weapons straight from manufacturers. Other than that, militant groups around the world constantly get weapons, so the idea isn't far fetched.
And on the topic of 'Robin': I'll admit, I cringed when they said his name. Luckily, I took heart in the knowledge that Nolan did say he's done with Batman now and is moving on. So, HOPEFULLY, we won't see that crap (really, where else can they take it? Can't do anything with the Joker, because you can't replace or replicate the magnificence that was Heath Ledger's performance. Bane is dead, Talia is dead, Ras is dead...they've lost pretty much every villain that they could use in the universe they've established.)
Overall, I really enjoyed the movie. Maybe I'm just not very particular or picky about my movies, but oh well
I'm not trying to crush anyone's opinions or points here, just offering my POV and opinions. Please don't flame me
CamoBadger- Royal Alicorn
- Posts : 13890
Brohoof! : 588
Join date : 2011-11-29
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
- Spoiler:
- Erumpet wrote:@Icy Shake: agree with you on all points. Just thought I'd point out that Talia wasn't interested in sustainable energy, she just pretended she was to get access to the reactor. While Fox's antics may have been illegal, they certainly kept the reactor hidden very well.
See, that's what I thought at first, and I'm fine with that as the explanation as such.But okay, let's assume she got in on Wayne Industries after its initial announcement (or, as later said, she was the one that got the ball rolling). In that case, why did she stick around forever after its apparent failure? Is it another case of clairvoyance, letting her know that the weapon she needs does exist? Did she just have that much confidence in it working? Looking at Wiki, it seems the project was hers to start, and WE invested in it and took it over [it's Wiki, so caveat emptor etc.]. Why structure the deal this way, rather than having some sort of joint partnership wherein she retains effective control? Did she need WE's tech that badly? It seemed like the breakthrough work was from the physicist they ended up capping.It's late, and I'm not thinking at my clearest. In any case, given her resources, wouldn't it have been easier to just get the materials for a nuke and make that? She could even get the timer effect through a timer or perhaps some sort of random number generator tied to a detonation code, if you wanted tension from an unknown *plewie* date. I guess it's just supervillainy and its quirks.
As for Fox: yes, that's fine as far as it goes. But shouldn't some sort of active investor started making inroads, applying pressure, and ultimately forcing the management out? I'm just taking that point too hard, I think. But I would expect that at least Fox would realize that, if you think about it, the weaponization issue already exists with nuclear power, if not to the same extremely portable extent. So the horse had already left the stable. And beyond everything else, I've just started thinking that Fox and Wayne are really, really terrible people, on the basis that you would have to be to build an experimental reactor with tremendous destructive potential underneath one of the most populated cities in the country. Without telling anybody. Isn't that the kind of thing you normally do a little bit farther away from population centers? I guess real fusion research is being done in, say, Livermore, California, but I guess I see a little difference between well-publicized research where the actual destructive potential is relatively minimal, if only because they would be ecstatic merely to break even on energy, and a generator that's actually outputting enough to power a city or whatever it achieved. Whatever, it's a comic book superhero movie. I just feel like I have to say that a few too many times, and in places where I shouldn't need to.
Icy Shake- Alicorn
- Posts : 1209
Brohoof! : 308
Join date : 2012-06-05
Age : 35
Location : Boston, MA
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
If it's any help, Silent, you aren't alone. This third movie was botched, badly. It wasn't just the fact that bane's presence was both incomprehensible and ham handed. It was from the launch onwards. The movie started with Bruce having been MIA for eight years. WTF? No. Batman doesn't do that. He'd go insane. The movie should have started with Batman taking down someone like Mad Hatter or Killer Croc. Albert comments that this really is no kind of a life and he's wondering what the endgame is. We should have seen Bruce in full Batman / Bruce juggling mode and introducing Talia as a woman who seems to 'care too much and knows too much' early on.
Suddenly Batman comes across a arms dealer who doesn't break. Who says there's someone in Gotham who's even scarier than the batman. Who says he's dead anyway... there's no protection. No escape. Infact, he's only alive to deliver this message... then he blows his own brains out rather than go to jail.
Batman does some investigating and finds a LOT of guns are coming into the city, but they're not hitting the streets. If they're not hitting the streets, there's no profit. Meeting with Gordon. Arkham is at capacity. Blackgate is OVER capacity. And there's a BnE at an energy subsidiary working on fusion... seems almost too smooth. Catwoman is involved. A chase, a fight, flirting over the stolen fusion core. Catwoman gets away....
We get a glimpse of Bane. She hands it over. He praises her. Then he asks a mook for a canister of tritium gas. The mook failed. We see a hand come out of the shadows. The mook bent like a fish bone, snap. Bane wants that tritum, but the only place that has it is Wayne Tech and she'd need Bruce's access to get the tanker of gas. Now Selina Kyle meets Wayne at a gala to address the poor and unfortunate. Talia asks if Bruce really thinks the city is worth it. If 99% are scum, why go through so much effort to save the 1%? Selina says 'hey, not everyone is an angel.' and Talia says that eventually gangrenous limbs must come off. Selina gets the access (biometric, whatever) and goes to flee when she comes across Talia, who lets her go?
Bane tells his minions to get ready to sieze the tritium. Ah, but what about the batman and the police? Ah... don't worry. Batman will be... occupied. Queue two suicide bombers blowing the front right off the prison. the bridges are severed. The tunnels are blasted. And then Bane himself blows the front off of Arkham. Batman's rogues all run for the hills, save the joker who snickers in his dark cell 'Oh, I just know the joke's gonna be on him...'
Now a montage. Batman working his ass off, fighting off thugs, beating down villains, wearing out as he tries desperately to save his city. Catwoman confronts him and says he shout quit while he's ahead; that this is gonna get him killed, and what the fuck is he fighting for anyway. Then she tells him that Bane is stealing the Tritium now and Bane told her to tell him. Batman, pushing the ragged edge, injects himself with adreniline to keep going. then bane steps out and calmly beats an exhausted batman, then snaps his back. So much for the hero.
Alfred comes to Bruce's rescue in the bat plane thing, and gets a doctor to help Bruce's spine after his 'accident' in the riots. Talia, of course, is there offering sympathy. Why doesn't he go away with her to Fiji. The city is in anarchy. People are killing at murdering... the 1% worth fighting for is gone! And he can't walk any more; he may never walk again! She'll take care of him... if he'll let her. Then she goes.
He stares out at the city. Alfred asks him why he doesn't accept. Bruce tells him that at the end of the day, Bruce Wayne is nothing without Batman, and Batman is nothing without Gotham. If he gives up on the city, what is to stop him from giving up on every remaining person in the world? Alfred says it's moot. After all, he can't be batman from a wheelchair.
Then bruce looks out at the city and wheels his way to the secret door to the bat cave He looks down all those stairs and begins to crawl down them. He drags himself through the bat cave to his computer and pulls himself on to his feet. Tottering, in agony, he glares at the computer and starts typing. Alfred finds him and asks what he's doing. Bruce asks why Bane hasn't nuked the city. He can't smuggle a whole tanker of tritium with a fusion bomb out of the city. So what is he waiting for. Indeed... he's not even sure if the fusion device would work like that.
So montage of him building the model, strugging to walk, failing to quit, meeting Talia in his chair, but wiring it up. He puts in the Tritum sample, powers it up. It makes plasma and then... Pop. The model fizzles and the power goes out... for five mils. Batman realizes that the EMP of the fusion reactor going off doesn't make a huge fireball like expected. No, it creates an EMP that destroys power infrastructure.... and worse. The EMP is trapped inside the earth's magnetic field. It'll expand, going farther and farther and destroying every power plant and generator in the world. Without power, the world is a few days away from ripping itself to pieces. Bane doesn't need to move the bomb. Once it has converted enough tritium to energized plasma, it'll cripple the world.
Unless Batman can stop him. And he has only weeks to pull it off. Batman works his body as he worked his mind. He simply can't wait for the doctors. He has to keep going. We see Selina looking at spoils taken in the rioting. We see bane making the energized plasma from the tritium. We see Bruce training, pushing through the pain. and also, trying to find out who hired bane...
Finally he's ready, it's the final night. And then Talia comes into the bat cave. She's known for years. She's watched him from afar, marvelling at his strength and dedication. He is a paragon of humanity... and Gotham and the world does not deserve his sacrifice. She pleas once more from him to join her. He refuses. Well... that's just too bad. And then she knifes him, driving him to his knees. This is a reboot for humanity. Her father worked to slow and too small. Humanity raped the planet for far too long... stab.... now it is going consume itself. Stab. It's just too bad that the future will be short one Paragon.
Then he's saved by Selina, who takes her out from behind. Batman drags himself to his feet, makes her staple his hide closed, and staggers to the bat plane. Selina's like... 'you're crazy and going to die.' 'There was only ever one end to this.' And wounded but determined, he goes out and faces Bane. Catwoman quips that the good ones are always the crazy ones... and then get's her head slammed by a bloody and really pissed off Talia.
Bruce flies over the city and Bane gets the call. 'I broke him once.' and then he picks up a missile launcher and blasts the batplane. It goes down, and Batman is dumped in the middle of the street. Out comes an army of thugs and criminals he helped put away. 'gonna fight all of us?' one thug asks. 'No. We are.' Gordon says as the police and a citizen army swarm forth to beat down the army of criminals.
Batman confronts Bane who bored asks what's different, really? He broke him once and he's still wounded and weak. But Batman isn't just a man. A man can be broken, silenced, killed. Batman is a symbol. An idea. A legend. and Bane, for all his strength and for all his intellect, is just a thug. A strong thug. A smart thug. But ultimately a thug. They fight, and batman injects him... Bane thanks him! He gets injected again. And again. And Batman is getting beaten as we hear a heartbeat going faster and faster, as Bane is getting faster and faster. And then suddenly he keels over, clutching his chest in agony. Now batman begins to beat HIM down. And every time he starts to put up a fight... another shot. Bane's heart is beating like a machine gun as he gasps for air. And then finally it stops. Bane collapses like a stack of bricks.
Then the tanker truck takes off. It's got ten minutes before the Plasma discharges the EMP and Talia is at the wheel. They rocket through the debris choked streets, kicking and fighting as she tries to stall. The gas pedal is floored. 'You fool, we'll both be killed!' 'Then I'll die saving this city. Are you going to die to destroy it?" And looking horrified and pissed, she jumps as it rockets down one of the blasted bridges. Batman stays at the wheel and steers it right off the edge as it starts to discharge, and then slams cab down into the river. Five seconds later the river glows a bright vivid blue. The city goes dark. From space, we see a huge chuck of the eastern seaboard go dark. In gotham, people stare up in the absolute darkness. Then the bat signal, wired to some car batteries, goes up. It shines on the clouds and the weary cops let out a shout.
To the denoument.... video clips of news reporting that the truck was dredged from the river with no body, but the EMP radiation would have fried him... right? People on the street, speculating on who the Batman was. The mayor saying 'I'd want to give him a medal and shake his hand, and then send him for twelve months of therapy.' Gordon saying that while he can not condone vigilantism, there comes a time for men to step up, to do better, and to give for for their common man. Alfred then meets Fox and signs over controlling shares of Wayne Industries to him, with a caveat that a significant portion goes to help both the world, and Gotham city. He then asks what Mr. Wayne will be doing on his 'extended vacation?'
Oh I don't know. What DO multi millionaire playboys do? Ziplining...' cut to batman swinging along a street. 'jogging.' Batman chasing down a crook. 'Boxing?'
'Protecting those who can't protect themselves?' and Alfred just smiles. End with dramatic music going up a building. Batman standing at the corner. Bat signal behind him. Then he dives, camera follows him, he shoots his grapnel gun and swings out of sight as everything flashes to black and then roll credits.
Anyway... that's how I would have done it.
Suddenly Batman comes across a arms dealer who doesn't break. Who says there's someone in Gotham who's even scarier than the batman. Who says he's dead anyway... there's no protection. No escape. Infact, he's only alive to deliver this message... then he blows his own brains out rather than go to jail.
Batman does some investigating and finds a LOT of guns are coming into the city, but they're not hitting the streets. If they're not hitting the streets, there's no profit. Meeting with Gordon. Arkham is at capacity. Blackgate is OVER capacity. And there's a BnE at an energy subsidiary working on fusion... seems almost too smooth. Catwoman is involved. A chase, a fight, flirting over the stolen fusion core. Catwoman gets away....
We get a glimpse of Bane. She hands it over. He praises her. Then he asks a mook for a canister of tritium gas. The mook failed. We see a hand come out of the shadows. The mook bent like a fish bone, snap. Bane wants that tritum, but the only place that has it is Wayne Tech and she'd need Bruce's access to get the tanker of gas. Now Selina Kyle meets Wayne at a gala to address the poor and unfortunate. Talia asks if Bruce really thinks the city is worth it. If 99% are scum, why go through so much effort to save the 1%? Selina says 'hey, not everyone is an angel.' and Talia says that eventually gangrenous limbs must come off. Selina gets the access (biometric, whatever) and goes to flee when she comes across Talia, who lets her go?
Bane tells his minions to get ready to sieze the tritium. Ah, but what about the batman and the police? Ah... don't worry. Batman will be... occupied. Queue two suicide bombers blowing the front right off the prison. the bridges are severed. The tunnels are blasted. And then Bane himself blows the front off of Arkham. Batman's rogues all run for the hills, save the joker who snickers in his dark cell 'Oh, I just know the joke's gonna be on him...'
Now a montage. Batman working his ass off, fighting off thugs, beating down villains, wearing out as he tries desperately to save his city. Catwoman confronts him and says he shout quit while he's ahead; that this is gonna get him killed, and what the fuck is he fighting for anyway. Then she tells him that Bane is stealing the Tritium now and Bane told her to tell him. Batman, pushing the ragged edge, injects himself with adreniline to keep going. then bane steps out and calmly beats an exhausted batman, then snaps his back. So much for the hero.
Alfred comes to Bruce's rescue in the bat plane thing, and gets a doctor to help Bruce's spine after his 'accident' in the riots. Talia, of course, is there offering sympathy. Why doesn't he go away with her to Fiji. The city is in anarchy. People are killing at murdering... the 1% worth fighting for is gone! And he can't walk any more; he may never walk again! She'll take care of him... if he'll let her. Then she goes.
He stares out at the city. Alfred asks him why he doesn't accept. Bruce tells him that at the end of the day, Bruce Wayne is nothing without Batman, and Batman is nothing without Gotham. If he gives up on the city, what is to stop him from giving up on every remaining person in the world? Alfred says it's moot. After all, he can't be batman from a wheelchair.
Then bruce looks out at the city and wheels his way to the secret door to the bat cave He looks down all those stairs and begins to crawl down them. He drags himself through the bat cave to his computer and pulls himself on to his feet. Tottering, in agony, he glares at the computer and starts typing. Alfred finds him and asks what he's doing. Bruce asks why Bane hasn't nuked the city. He can't smuggle a whole tanker of tritium with a fusion bomb out of the city. So what is he waiting for. Indeed... he's not even sure if the fusion device would work like that.
So montage of him building the model, strugging to walk, failing to quit, meeting Talia in his chair, but wiring it up. He puts in the Tritum sample, powers it up. It makes plasma and then... Pop. The model fizzles and the power goes out... for five mils. Batman realizes that the EMP of the fusion reactor going off doesn't make a huge fireball like expected. No, it creates an EMP that destroys power infrastructure.... and worse. The EMP is trapped inside the earth's magnetic field. It'll expand, going farther and farther and destroying every power plant and generator in the world. Without power, the world is a few days away from ripping itself to pieces. Bane doesn't need to move the bomb. Once it has converted enough tritium to energized plasma, it'll cripple the world.
Unless Batman can stop him. And he has only weeks to pull it off. Batman works his body as he worked his mind. He simply can't wait for the doctors. He has to keep going. We see Selina looking at spoils taken in the rioting. We see bane making the energized plasma from the tritium. We see Bruce training, pushing through the pain. and also, trying to find out who hired bane...
Finally he's ready, it's the final night. And then Talia comes into the bat cave. She's known for years. She's watched him from afar, marvelling at his strength and dedication. He is a paragon of humanity... and Gotham and the world does not deserve his sacrifice. She pleas once more from him to join her. He refuses. Well... that's just too bad. And then she knifes him, driving him to his knees. This is a reboot for humanity. Her father worked to slow and too small. Humanity raped the planet for far too long... stab.... now it is going consume itself. Stab. It's just too bad that the future will be short one Paragon.
Then he's saved by Selina, who takes her out from behind. Batman drags himself to his feet, makes her staple his hide closed, and staggers to the bat plane. Selina's like... 'you're crazy and going to die.' 'There was only ever one end to this.' And wounded but determined, he goes out and faces Bane. Catwoman quips that the good ones are always the crazy ones... and then get's her head slammed by a bloody and really pissed off Talia.
Bruce flies over the city and Bane gets the call. 'I broke him once.' and then he picks up a missile launcher and blasts the batplane. It goes down, and Batman is dumped in the middle of the street. Out comes an army of thugs and criminals he helped put away. 'gonna fight all of us?' one thug asks. 'No. We are.' Gordon says as the police and a citizen army swarm forth to beat down the army of criminals.
Batman confronts Bane who bored asks what's different, really? He broke him once and he's still wounded and weak. But Batman isn't just a man. A man can be broken, silenced, killed. Batman is a symbol. An idea. A legend. and Bane, for all his strength and for all his intellect, is just a thug. A strong thug. A smart thug. But ultimately a thug. They fight, and batman injects him... Bane thanks him! He gets injected again. And again. And Batman is getting beaten as we hear a heartbeat going faster and faster, as Bane is getting faster and faster. And then suddenly he keels over, clutching his chest in agony. Now batman begins to beat HIM down. And every time he starts to put up a fight... another shot. Bane's heart is beating like a machine gun as he gasps for air. And then finally it stops. Bane collapses like a stack of bricks.
Then the tanker truck takes off. It's got ten minutes before the Plasma discharges the EMP and Talia is at the wheel. They rocket through the debris choked streets, kicking and fighting as she tries to stall. The gas pedal is floored. 'You fool, we'll both be killed!' 'Then I'll die saving this city. Are you going to die to destroy it?" And looking horrified and pissed, she jumps as it rockets down one of the blasted bridges. Batman stays at the wheel and steers it right off the edge as it starts to discharge, and then slams cab down into the river. Five seconds later the river glows a bright vivid blue. The city goes dark. From space, we see a huge chuck of the eastern seaboard go dark. In gotham, people stare up in the absolute darkness. Then the bat signal, wired to some car batteries, goes up. It shines on the clouds and the weary cops let out a shout.
To the denoument.... video clips of news reporting that the truck was dredged from the river with no body, but the EMP radiation would have fried him... right? People on the street, speculating on who the Batman was. The mayor saying 'I'd want to give him a medal and shake his hand, and then send him for twelve months of therapy.' Gordon saying that while he can not condone vigilantism, there comes a time for men to step up, to do better, and to give for for their common man. Alfred then meets Fox and signs over controlling shares of Wayne Industries to him, with a caveat that a significant portion goes to help both the world, and Gotham city. He then asks what Mr. Wayne will be doing on his 'extended vacation?'
Oh I don't know. What DO multi millionaire playboys do? Ziplining...' cut to batman swinging along a street. 'jogging.' Batman chasing down a crook. 'Boxing?'
'Protecting those who can't protect themselves?' and Alfred just smiles. End with dramatic music going up a building. Batman standing at the corner. Bat signal behind him. Then he dives, camera follows him, he shoots his grapnel gun and swings out of sight as everything flashes to black and then roll credits.
Anyway... that's how I would have done it.
Somber- Hydra
- Posts : 538
Brohoof! : 1046
Join date : 2012-05-09
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
Oh that's how you would have done it Somber? Yeah no big deal guys, I didn't think about it that much but if I had done it, it would make sense and be awesome and sexy and stuff. You know I'm not disrespecting those guys, it's just I would have done a good job. Really though, you just rewrote the entire movie in a way that reconciled it with all the way the characters are supposed to act, while still staying true to the general plot of the movie, and making it more realistic. Well done at totally ruining any enjoyment I would have ever gotten from this movie in the future, and making me love you for it.
@Icy Shake: I disagree with her capability to get or make a nucleur bomb. Al Queda hasn't gotten the bomb with all the resources of Saudi Arabia at their disposal, I don't think a couple dozen mercenaries, no matter how trained or fanatical, would be able to get a nuke. But I've never tried to get a nuke so this is all just speculation on my part.
@Icy Shake: I disagree with her capability to get or make a nucleur bomb. Al Queda hasn't gotten the bomb with all the resources of Saudi Arabia at their disposal, I don't think a couple dozen mercenaries, no matter how trained or fanatical, would be able to get a nuke. But I've never tried to get a nuke so this is all just speculation on my part.
222222- Ursa Major
- Posts : 769
Brohoof! : 34
Join date : 2012-07-01
Character List:
Name:
Sex:
Species:
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
@Erumpet (PSN)
- I used to play MW2 (<3 AK-47) and the newer CoD games a lot, but it's been a while since I've been on, unfortunately.
@Kattlarv
- Well I'm very sorry to hear you've had such a difficult life, ma'am... no one deserves to have such bad things happen to them.
@MLPOCG
- I may not agree with what you see as weak points in the story (merely my opinions, of course), but do allow me to extend you a warm welcome, sir. I hope you enjoy what time you spend here.
I still love that original first chapter.
@tylertoon2 (FoE the Game trailer)
- Surprisingly... I find myself very... uninterested after watching that. It just gives me a bad feeling, I don't know why.
@(Batman)
- I'll take the first film from 1966 or Batman Forever any day. Modern movies can keep their fancy shenanigans.
- I used to play MW2 (<3 AK-47) and the newer CoD games a lot, but it's been a while since I've been on, unfortunately.
@Kattlarv
- Well I'm very sorry to hear you've had such a difficult life, ma'am... no one deserves to have such bad things happen to them.
@MLPOCG
- I may not agree with what you see as weak points in the story (merely my opinions, of course), but do allow me to extend you a warm welcome, sir. I hope you enjoy what time you spend here.
Sir, I've always been impressed by how, given such limited resources as the Fallout Equestria world does, that you've managed to keep your fights all so different and interesting. There hasn't been a single boring fight yet.Somber wrote:Still, my greatest fear is that the story will become boring. Which... the constant fighting does.... I'm doomed!
This, very much so. I think I've backed up my copy of the original chapter 1 in seven different places on other computers and stick/portable drives.O. Hinds wrote:Oh hush. Yes, you've improved, but the original, unbrushed first two chapters were still enough to suck me in. And I, as you know, am picky.
I still love that original first chapter.
@tylertoon2 (FoE the Game trailer)
- Surprisingly... I find myself very... uninterested after watching that. It just gives me a bad feeling, I don't know why.
@(Batman)
- I'll take the first film from 1966 or Batman Forever any day. Modern movies can keep their fancy shenanigans.
WavemasterRyx- Hydra
- Posts : 599
Brohoof! : 376
Join date : 2012-05-09
Age : 39
Location : Happyhorn Gardens
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
@Silent: (Batman) I do believe Bob goes through most of that in: http://www.escapistmagazine.com/videos/view/escape-to-the-movies/6064-The-Dark-Knight-Rises
@Somber and C:O: (Batman) Use spoilers for spoiling things guys :P And hehe, seems like my late night rambling was saved by batman xD
@Wave: Thanks... and eh, I'm used to it. As said, I'm rather numb/jaded to be bothered by most things as much any more.
@Somber and C:O: (Batman) Use spoilers for spoiling things guys :P And hehe, seems like my late night rambling was saved by batman xD
@Wave: Thanks... and eh, I'm used to it. As said, I'm rather numb/jaded to be bothered by most things as much any more.
Kattlarv- Hydra
- Posts : 560
Brohoof! : 27
Join date : 2012-05-10
Location : Sweden
Character List:
Name: Dewflower
Sex: Female-ish
Species: Unicorn
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
Hello everypony! This is the Project Horizons main comment thread right? Sorry if my entry is sudden, I've just finished every chapter up-to-date (chp. 48) and I'm absolutely thrilled with the story, like some of the posts earlier in this thread have said, the books they made myself and others read back when I was in school were overall boring especially when we analyzed them to death, but the way this story is being told makes it very interesting, evolving even, with each chapter bringing anticipation for the next. It reminds of when I was little and the anticipation I had each week of seeing the next episode of Dragonball, I remember my mother bringing me popcorn once because of how much she knew I liked the show.
As for analyzing and such, this is the first story I've read where talking about it with others is fun too! Not to mention it seems to be pretty intellectually stimulating at times. (Though I've heard there can be some... "interesting topics" from time to time, but I don't mind haha.) It really is good to finally meet you all as well.
Btw, so people don't have to fool with my username, just call me obs, short for observancy.
Hmm, now that I'm here, I wonder what the first order of business should be?
As for analyzing and such, this is the first story I've read where talking about it with others is fun too! Not to mention it seems to be pretty intellectually stimulating at times. (Though I've heard there can be some... "interesting topics" from time to time, but I don't mind haha.) It really is good to finally meet you all as well.
Btw, so people don't have to fool with my username, just call me obs, short for observancy.
Hmm, now that I'm here, I wonder what the first order of business should be?
OBS.GS.§S- Colt/Filly
- Posts : 42
Brohoof! : 5
Join date : 2012-05-24
Age : 30
Location : USA
Character List:
Name: Flashpoint
Sex: Female
Species: Earth Pony
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
It's coo. General rules in these topics are...I forgot half of them, but they are on the frontpage of one of the older threads :P
Can say though what I recall, don't speak about rape to much, don't poke at Somber to much and some "spoiler" hidden content are hidden for a reason, like many of my and Kipper's posts especially, (like when I invented the "spitting cobra"! Wait, I never talked about that out loud did I? Ah well, better for the sanity of you guys ;D) so thread with caution there ;P
Can say though what I recall, don't speak about rape to much, don't poke at Somber to much and some "spoiler" hidden content are hidden for a reason, like many of my and Kipper's posts especially, (like when I invented the "spitting cobra"! Wait, I never talked about that out loud did I? Ah well, better for the sanity of you guys ;D) so thread with caution there ;P
Kattlarv- Hydra
- Posts : 560
Brohoof! : 27
Join date : 2012-05-10
Location : Sweden
Character List:
Name: Dewflower
Sex: Female-ish
Species: Unicorn
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
Yep, you've found the discussion thread. I bid you welcome.OBS.GS.§S wrote:
I agree with you completely, when you are required to analyze something you don't care for, it just gets boring and tedious. Looking through something closely that you are truly interested by, and discussing it, is a lot more enjoyable. Somber is excelling at keeping it interesting, I say.
Anyhow, welcome to Project Horizon's rather erratic discussion thread.
Ketchup- The Condiment
- Posts : 4891
Brohoof! : 114
Join date : 2012-05-09
Age : 26
Location : New Brunswick, Canada
Character List:
Name:
Sex:
Species:
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
Icy Shake wrote:Now we get to the stuff that very few people likely care about: the financial and legal details.
- Spoiler:
- Yeah, as a computer professional, I whispered to my brother, "So just roll back the transactions!" What's all this business about it taking months to prove fraud? You had armed men shooting people in the stock exchange! I think you can assume that even thumbprint-confirmed transactions are void in that circumstance. It's easy enough to obtain a thumbprint when you're holding a gun to someone's head.
Also, Batman majorly grabbed the idiot ball by not firing his EMP rifle at the guy with the computer. That'd halt the transaction REAL quick, don'tcha think?
SilentCarto- Alicorn
- Posts : 1585
Brohoof! : 393
Join date : 2012-05-08
Age : 44
Location : Texas
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
That was another problem I had with the plot, but it's mostly real physics vs. comic book physics. A nuclear bomb -- one that's intended to explode -- is a phenomenally complicated device. If you started putting bullets into it, you wouldn't set it off -- you'd damage it beyond repair. They had to develop new types of detonators just to make sure all the implosion charges went off within the same microsecond. You could disable it simply by damaging the detonators, and even if your gunfire set off the explosives, it would just squirt the core out the side of the bomb instead of triggering a fission chain reaction.Icy Shake wrote:In any case, given her resources, wouldn't it have been easier to just get the materials for a nuke and make that?
Well, so now you have an improvised nuclear bomb that you have specially rigged to explode when you push a button. You're seriously going to tell me that smashing up random equipment with a crowbar isn't going to disrupt your preparations that required a nuclear physicist to develop? And that's setting aside the entire point that "fusion does not work that way"... plus, wasn't flooding the reactor room supposed to douse the reaction? Remind me why we couldn't just dunk it in the bay, again?
SilentCarto- Alicorn
- Posts : 1585
Brohoof! : 393
Join date : 2012-05-08
Age : 44
Location : Texas
Re: [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
Erumpet wrote:Oh that's how you would have done it Somber? Yeah no big deal guys, I didn't think about it that much but if I had done it, it would make sense and be awesome and sexy and stuff. You know I'm not disrespecting those guys, it's just I would have done a good job. Really though, you just rewrote the entire movie in a way that reconciled it with all the way the characters are supposed to act, while still staying true to the general plot of the movie, and making it more realistic. Well done at totally ruining any enjoyment I would have ever gotten from this movie in the future, and making me love you for it.
@Icy Shake: I disagree with her capability to get or make a nucleur bomb. Al Queda hasn't gotten the bomb with all the resources of Saudi Arabia at their disposal, I don't think a couple dozen mercenaries, no matter how trained or fanatical, would be able to get a nuke. But I've never tried to get a nuke so this is all just speculation on my part.
I'm sorry! But some of the movie really needed to BE rewritten.
@OBS. Welcome! That's Two! Two new ponies for us to play with!
Somber- Hydra
- Posts : 538
Brohoof! : 1046
Join date : 2012-05-09
Page 18 of 31 • 1 ... 10 ... 17, 18, 19 ... 24 ... 31
Similar topics
» [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
» [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
» [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
» [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
» [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
» [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
» [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
» [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
» [GRIMDARK] Fallout Equestria: Project Horizons Discussion
Page 18 of 31
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|